Adult esl students perceptions of native and nonnative english speaking teachers. The experiences of nonnative english speaking teachers and their professional identity constructions in an esl context welcome to the ideals repository javascript is disabled for your browser. In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of. Eric ed492599 native and nonnative englishspeaking.
Because the term nets is widely used by local educators and researchers, it is used in this article to refer to nests in hong kong. Developing spoken corpora of nonnative english teachers. The advantages of being a non native english speaking teacher. Appraisal of native and nonnative english speaking teachers. However, nativelike accurate and fluent speedy pronunciation is likely to be the most problematic aspect to come up. What matters is their experience, qualifications and proficiency. Do you think native english speakers are better teachers than those of us who learned english as a second language. It seems that both native english speakers and nonnative english speakers. The issue of native and nonnative speakers of english, relevant to a large number of questions in applied linguistics, is mainly important if related to native and nonnative englishspeaking teachers of english as a second or foreign language. The english language teaching industry in east and southeast asia subscribes to an assumption that native englishspeaking teachers. Some of these difficulties will be dependent on what is the first language of the teacher. Whether someone speaks english as their first language doesnt matter. This article addresses the challenges that nonnative englishspeaking teacher trainees face as they begin teaching english as a second language esl in western, englishspeaking countries. Native and nonnative english speaking student teachers engage in peer feedback introduction the teaching of writing in secondsubsequent language l2 teacher education programs has typically received little attention in the curriculum.
Cee dp 7 nonnative speakers of english in the classroom. To sum up, a good english teacher can be either a native or nonnative speaker of english. A perception analysis the institute of economics and social sciences of bilkent university by ebru ezberci in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of master of arts in the department of teaching english as a foreign language. Nativespeaking teachers nsts are not always nsts and nonnsts are not always nonnsts. Native and non native english speaking eslefl teachers. Native and nonnative english speaking student teachers. All of your correspondence should be in a professional manner and written in. A small number of the students were less satisfied with nonnative teachers command of the english language teaching in different social contexts.
For decades there has been a longstanding fallacy in the field of english language teaching that native. In this context, a detail study will be conducted to find out the role and contribution of non nests and nests in uk and english speaking nations. Nonnativespeaking teachers of english as a foreign. The subjects of the study were six native english teachers nests and six nonnative english teachers nnests, and their 196 grade ten students in the institute of applied technology in the uae.
The demand in this field is try to be filled largely by nonnative english speaking teachers who have learned english in the country or abroad. Native englishspeaking teachers versus nonnative english. The number of learners of english as an international means of communication increases hand in hand with the number of nonnative englishspeaking teachers nnests of english as a second language esl and the number of native english. It is often combined with reading, or simply as part of a general course on teaching methodology. The nonnative english speaking eflesl teachers self. Both native and nonnative professionals have raised their voices against the widespread idea that an ideal english teacher is a native english speaking teacher nest. However, the problem is not so simple, because it does not only go in one direction. Thus, the latter results cannot be extrapolated to other contexts.
Pdf advantages and disadvantages of nativeand nonnative. Native and non native native english speaking eslefl teachers in sweden. Put differently, nonnative speakers of english find it hard to compete with native speakers on equal terms, and this linguistic handicap applies to nonnative. What problems face nonnative speaking teachers of english. This paper will discuss good english language teachers focusing on the argument.
Abstract an abstract of the thesis of kathryn ann long for the master of arts in teaching english to speakers of other languages presented june 27, 2003. When it comes to choosing an english teacher, the first choice that needs to be made is between a local nonnative teacher and a native english speaker. But nests have a head start in that the vast majority of jobs require native speakers. History and research article pdf available in language teaching 4103 july 2008 with 8,359 reads how we measure reads. To meet these demands, teachers with native and nonnative english individuals have been competing for the purpose of teaching english. The issue of native and nonnative teachers of english. Nonnative teachers attitudes towards english as a lingua franca 241 should be the longterm goal ibid 243. Native english teacher specialized in skype english classes.
Advantages and disadvantages of nests and nnests 283. Nonnative speakers of english teaching english in japan. While esl teachers push to make students use as little of their native language as possible, sometimes its not as easy as it seems. Selfperceptions of nonnative english speaking teachers. Such positive selection means that nonnative speakers may have characteristics than compensate for any lack of language fluency. Master of arts english as a second language, december 2004, 89 pp. This paper discusses possible advantages of having nonnative englishspeaking teachers nnests to teach english as a foreignlanguage efl especially in asian countries when they are often. So a lot of native speakers dont know the underlying grammar that goes for any language but teachers will. Nonnative teachers, on the other hand, were perceived as role models, empathetic, better culturally aware and capable of delivering efficient instructions. The term native english teacher is most often used for english teachers who teach the language to nonnative english speakers, either in a nonenglish speaking country or to immigrants who have moved to an english speaking country. The instrument of the study was a speaking test implemented at the end of term one of the academic year 20082009. The purpose of this article is to see what can be done to counter this stereotype.
The term was coined to highlight the dichotomy between native englishspeaking teachers nest and nonnative englishspeaking teachers nnest. In many countries the primary mother tongue language is not english but there is a great demand for english language teachers all over the world. Nnest or nonnative englishspeaking teachers is an acronym that refers to the growing body of english language teachers who speak english as a foreign or. Im a nonnative esl teacher, and im afraid im at a disadvantage when compared to native english speakers. Advantages and disadvantages of native and nonnative englishspeaking teachers. If youre a native english speaker teacher nest then youll have seen an abundance of teaching opportunities out there. This study discusses some issues regarding nativeness in english language teaching. For instance, in spanishspeaking countries, it is not uncommon for children to learn english from teachers who explain through translation, in the students native language. Im committed to ensuring that each of my students is left with a smile on their face and a richer knowledge of the english language. To be able to analyse whether native or non native english teaching speakers are the better teachers, i have decided to make my own study and ask language students about the experiences they had with the native and non native teachers they were taught by during their language learning processes. The number of learners of english as an international means of communication increases hand in hand with the number of nonnative englishspeaking teachers nnests of english as a second language esl and the number of native englishspeaking esl teachers nests. What are the advantages and the disadvantages of non. Nonnative englishspeaking english language teachers. A study on students attitudes and perceptions towards the teaching behavior of native and nonenglish speaking teachers c essay eric brown vt20 c essay, 15 hp english with emphasis on teaching methods english 6190 teacher program supervisor.
Five native and five nonnative teachers who were teaching at the university level in thailand were interviewed through three stages of data collection. Despite a great deal of training, nonnative speaker teachers may be viewed as inadequate language teachers because they often lack native speaker competence in the target language and culture. Although there is a little chance to learn english through natural interaction in the target language, due to the fact that there are some native speakers of english and many nonarabic speaking people working and. The experiences of nonnative english speaking teachers. I can imagine that a number of readers might also realize one important fact. Advantages and disadvantages of native and nonnative. This study attempted to investigate native and nonnative english speaking teachers beliefs about written corrective feedback. But for a nonnative english speaker teacher nnest, its a different story. Student perceptions in hong kong, abstract the native english teachers nets scheme has been in place for over 20 years in secondary schools in hong kong and yet how students perceive these teachers is. Collaboration between native and nonnative englishspeaking teachers mohammad nurul islam 1 abstract. While the nativenonnative speaker polemic seems to have abated, research on the special role played by nonnative teachers in the teachinglearning operation has been gaining ground. Llurda, 2005 have estimated nonnative english speakers to account for.
Efl college students perceptions toward native and non. The purpose of this study was to investigate taiwanese english as a foreign language efl students perceptions and preferences toward native englishspeaking teachersnests and nonnative englishspeaking teachers nnests who hold a degree from a country where english is the dominant language through addressing the differences of their english instruction. Im a highly qualified native english teacher from the coastal town of plymouth in the southwest of england. Student attitudes, teacher selfperceptions, and intensive english administrator beliefs and practices a thesis submitted to the faculty of purdue university by lucie m. Online esl jobs for nonnative english teachers oetjobs. Nonnative speakers of english in the field of tesol. Assistant language teachers from english speaking countries have easily found work in japan because the boards of education are trying to improve student pronunciation and native speakers have encouraged more. The effect of native and nonnative english language.
Native and nonnative english speakers in english teaching in examining elementary school teachers english proficiencies, it is important to note that the korean government is planning to increase the number of nativeenglishspeaking nes teachers in their english classes yang, 2002. Although the majority of english language teachers worldwide are nonnative english speakers, no research was conducted on these teachers until recently. In fact, on, a leading website for english teaching jobs, only 30%. Up to 70 per cent of all jobs advertised on the biggest job search engine for english teachers are for nests yes, i have counted.
English speaking teachers nest as opposed to nonnative english speaking. In this paper we look at the association between the percentage of nonnative english speakers in the year group and the educational attainment of native english speakers at the. The english language teaching industry in east and southeast asia subscribes to an assumption that native english speaking teachers nests are the gold standard of spoken and written language, whereas non native english speaking teachers non nests are inferior educators because they lack this innate linguistic skill. But both strategies suggest that negative effects of nonnative english speakers can be ruled out. State school teachers are overwhelmingly nonnative english speakers in nonnative english speaking countries. Teachers of english to speakers of other languages tesol organization in 2003 in. Working with international students in the uk, kuo 2006 discovered that, although her participants accepted a degree of inaccurate pronunciation.
Native and nonnative english speaking eslefl teachers in. Nonnative teachers attitudes towards english as a lingua. A native english teacher, sometimes called a native english speaking teacher and abbreviated nest, is an english teacher whose first language is english. How are nonnativeenglishspeaking teachers perceived by. On the other hand, nonnativespeaking efl teachers have a number of disadvantages as compared to native speakers. The term was coined to highlight the dichotomy between native englishspeaking teachers nest and nonnative englishspeaking teachers nnest issues related to nnests attract the attention. The native english teachers nets scheme has been in place for over 20 years in secondary schools in hong kong and yet how students perceive these teachers is under. After the pioneering work of robert phillipson in 1992 and peter medgyes in 1994, nearly a decade had to elapse for more research to emerge on the issues relating to nonnative english teachers. Let me answer the question native or nonnative english teacher. Preparing nonnative englishspeaking esl teachers eric. Selfperceptions of nonnative english speaking teachers of english as a. This study is designed to be an empirical study of the nature of the collaboration between three nests and three taiwanese teachers of english ttes, who are nnests, in elementary schools in taiwan.
However, in addition to a growing number of articles 2, only one fulllength book, entitled the nonnative teacher medgyes, 1994, has been written on the subject. The native english teachers nets scheme has been in place for over 20. Pdf appraisal of native and nonnative english speaking teachers. Enabling english teachers in japan, who are in most cases nonnative speakers of english, to teach communicative english has been a key element in the english education reform plan of japans ministry of education, sports, science, culture, and technology hereafter, mext proposed in 20. This article reports a study which analyses student perceptions of the advantage and disadvantages of learning english from nets and their non.
Native english teacher or non native english teacher. Ive successfully taught business and conversational english in the uk, france, austria and romania. Collaboration between native and nonnative english. Selfperceptions, and intensive english administrator beliefs and practices. Nonnative english speakers already teach english in state schools, so there are plenty of teaching opportunities.
563 849 713 1380 810 249 562 1224 345 1481 178 12 372 481 883 418 694 1004 1075 1488 279 209 551 242 453 718 184 1149 439 45 51